“Making Democracy Pointless” should be the new tagline of North Carolina government. The Republican Party has seized nearly election-proof and court-proof control of choosing the state’s representatives in Congress. Their methods were mostly legal, but that doesn’t make them ethical. The harm they have done extends beyond the actions of the officials they elected. They have confirmed cynical suspicion that our votes don’t matter – that democracy is indeed pointless. That is a terrible fate for government of, by and for the people.
Here’s how they did it:
- Prior to 2010 elections, the Washington DC based Republican State Leadership Committee (RSLC) contributed $1.25 million to “Real Jobs NC” an organization launched by wealthy Republican donors including Art Pope. By targeting about two dozen state legislative races for huge spending and attack ads against Democrats, they won both the house and the senate. That put Republicans firmly in charge of drawing congressional districts after the 2010 census.
- The RSLCs map making team, armed with exceptionally sophisticated computer technology and data, were hired by the Republican legislature to draft congressional district maps. Some work was supervised on-site by Art Pope, who was retained as co-counsel to the legislature. The map-making strategy was simple – pack large concentrations of Democratic voters and African Americans into just 3 of North Carolina’s congressional districts. The remaining 10 districts would favor Republicans. The maps were tested prior to adoption by checking how voters in each new district voted in the last election. The tests demonstrated that John McCain carried all ten of the “Republican” districts in the 2008 Presidential election despite losing the state to President Obama.
2012 election results proved the effectiveness of the Republican maneuvers. With only 49 percent of the votes, Republicans won 69 percent of congressional races and changed the North Carolina congressional delegation from a 7-6 Democrat majority to a 9-4 Republican advantage. In 2014 they achieved their desired 10-3 split. Democrats won the 3 districts into which they had been packed with over 70 percent of the vote.
North Carolina is one example of the national Republican gerrymandering strategy. Their website brags that, “Democratic candidates for the U.S. House won 1.1 million more votes than their Republican opponents. But the Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives is a Republican and presides over a 33-seat House Republican majority during the 113th Congress.” How much difference did gerrymandering make? Imagine the last four years with a narrow Democratic majority in the House of Representatives and a Democrat as Speaker of the House. It probably made that much difference.
Republicans defend their actions by pointing out that Democrats did the same thing when they were in power. It’s true. Modern computer technology and data may have made Republicans more effective, but there’s no doubt that Democrats gerrymandered. Recently a few states including California and Iowa have implemented non-partisan or bi-partisan redistricting plans as attempts to assure fair elections.
Meanwhile, North Carolina’s maps have been thrown out by a panel of federal judges who ruled that the influence of African American voters was unfairly reduced by packing the great majority of them into only three districts. The US Supreme Court has declined to hear a Republican appeal. North Carolina Republicans objected loudly to the court’s decision but they were well prepared for it. They have proudly presented new maps which they say are designed keep their current 10-3 advantage in the congressional delegation.
The court forbade gerrymandering to disenfranchise a race of people. But gerrymandering for partisan advantage is merely unethical, not illegal. Republicans intend to select their voters again, rather than allowing voters to select their representatives. And it seems unlikely that courts will stop them.
We need new redistricting laws at the state or federal level to preserve our democracy. There are Republicans as well as Democrats who feel the shame of cheating to win elections and who want fair redistricting. Now is a fine time time for all who value representative democracy to do what we know is right by creating districts without unfair advantages for any group or party.
Copy of my comment in the Courier Trib. online.
So this is not new for the Carolina’s is it? When I first came to NC in 1963 I was amazed but this is a tradition from reconstruction. You see, the Agricultural businesses imported so many slaves to compete favorably, their troubles were multiplied when the slaves were freed so the leadership found many ways to keep the “negro” down. Anyone opposing these aggressive political moves were placed in a category with the blacks and called the “Liberals”. Let no one speak up against North Carolina politics while this elite rule continues over here on the GOP side; or else all of the things liberals (and progressives) are accuse of become that person’s political rap sheet. Say all you want about the Zionist, their closest friends in Amertica are all for the survival of the Colonialist culture and will place opponents in a burlap bag and tie the string as long as they are able. Themes dating to Regan include the political speak of American Exceptionalism where Conservatives lead the world in a new (old) order. If athletics are any indication, and there are many more, people of color can compete well against Conservatives and that is the fear that drives elections for the same leadership that draws the Gerrymandered lines. But there is no shame in unfairness if power is held onto.