I don’t know whether to thank or curse Ken Burns and PBS for bringing back the ghosts of the Vietnam War – exhuming feelings and memories that I had buried deep in the past.
TO WATCH THE SERIES CLICK HERE
I can again see the ghost of Thích Quảng Đức, a Buddhist monk who doused himself with gasoline and set himself ablaze on a Saigon street in June, 1963. He was protesting actions of the US-supported South Vietnamese government. Although the nation was more than 70 percent Buddhist, French and American military had supported a Christian-dominated government that severely limited religious freedom and Buddhist participation in society. His last words were, “Before closing my eyes and moving towards the vision of the Buddha, I respectfully plead to President Ngô Đình Diệm to take a mind of compassion towards the people of the nation and implement religious equality to maintain the strength of the homeland eternally. I call the venerables, reverends, members of the sangha and the lay Buddhists to organize in solidarity to make sacrifices to protect Buddhism.”
When it became apparent that the Buddhist majority would oppose the government, the US supported a coup by the South Vietnamese military and ramped up the American troop presence to fight against a North Vietnamese government spawned from resistance to French colonialism. Simply stated, we took a side in a Vietnamese civil war. The Soviet Union and China took the other side.
An American Quaker pacifist, Norman Morrison (no relation that I know of) became my second ghost. He poured kerosene over himself and lit his fire under the office window of Robert McNamara, the US Secretary of defense. At least half a dozen other Americans and far more Vietnamese committed similar self-sacrifices to protest the war.
Those ghosts urged me to abandon the blind trust of American foreign policy and wars that was taught in our public school history books. If we were on the side of freedom, justice and fairness, why would people commit such horrific suicides to bring attention to the actions of the South Vietnamese government that we enabled?
The war soon became personal. By the time I finished high school in 1965 I knew that boys who graduated one or two years ahead of me had already died in Vietnam. I got a draft deferment because I went to college. Then came the lottery. I drew #51 – sure to be drafted for a war that I did not believe in – to invade a nation of people who had done me no harm and try to kill them before they killed me. I didn’t want to go but didn’t want to go to Canada or dodge the draft some other way…what to do??? In 1969 I went for my draft physical and flunked it because I was a few pounds underweight – 6’1″ and 123 pounds. I’m still not convinced that their scale was right but didn’t argue. 48 years have gone by since that physical exam and I still wonder what I would have done if I’d passed.
Today, I am haunted by the ghosts of those who gave their lives serving in our armed forces, and those who died fighting on the other side. They are joined by ghosts of American college students killed by American soldiers during an anti-war protest at Kent State University. The government of Vietnam estimates that two million of the ghosts were civilians whose lives were lost in the no man’s land of war.
We don’t see many protests against today’s sanitized wars. Precision munitions, guided from safe locations, assure that most of the death and suffering is among foreigners. The men and women (some barely older than boys and girls) who fight our wars are volunteers. They don’t complain much. Can they trust the rest of us to send them to war only in support of self-defense, freedom, justice and fairness?
I hope that others will also watch the PBS documentary and apply whatever lessons you find to 21st century America. Those who are as old as me are likely to find some ghosts of your own – including friends and family who died in the war. We have enough of them. We do not need more ghosts.
The Ken Burns doco is excellent. Especially telling are the intermittent commentaries from NVA and VC soldiers. They are offering comments which are much in line with my perspective as a former grunt and combat photojournalist.
I feared the combat sequences might provoke much suppressed anguish. That has not been the case. Viewers should read Nick Turse’s “ Kill Anything That Moves” as soon as the Burns series concludes. The total corruption of the US government toward both the accidental and systematic slaughter of Vietnamese civilians is uncovered by a chance find by the author in the US Archives. More than 2 million innocents were killed by American exceptionalism run amok.
My strongest emotional reaction has been the profound sense of betrayal I feel toward the architects of the Iraq invasion. With the sordid lessons of Vietnam still fresh in our minds, Cheyney, Wolfiwicz, Bremmer, Rumsfeld lied to the American people and involved us in another pointless, never ending civil war. In my mind they committed treason against America just like Kennedy, Johnson, and Nixon. I honestly feel powerful hatred toward them, and I feel their execution for treason would not be unreasonable. The death penalty totally fits their treasonous lies and malfeasance.
Thank you, Bill. I hope more veterans of the war will comment. The ones that I know seem just as divided in their thoughts about the war as the rest of the nation…
Bob,
I appreciate your sentiments. You clearly understood, in real time, the hypocrisy of our government. I was 17 when I volunteered for the Army in 1972. I was the son of a First Sergeant of a medical company. I joined to travel and see the world. Trying to achieve some goal to gain love and acceptance from my father and to make him proud. In basic training, I almost vomited realizing I was training to kill others. Six months in, I realized what a mistake I made. I was fortunate that a drawl down was taking place in Vietnam and I was shipped to Germany. My platoon leader was a drafted second lieutenant, great guy who watched out for foolish 18 year olds. I witnessed a lot of PTSD and substance abuse post Vietnam . Sobering!! Ken Burns and Lynn Novick have truly done a remarkable job covering the many facets of the history of Vietnam and US at a such a pressure point. Of all the things that have struck me about this series, it is how early on Vietnam was politically and militarily doomed to fail. From my experience as a soldier, I became very cynical about my government and ashamed of my country. What I fear now is a president who has no listening skills or a sense of history and a party that rationalizes his behavior to justify actions that isolate us from a rich world of diversity. We cannot allow our leaders to encourage a culture of hate and fear. Unfortunately they see nation building as weak instead of a wise strategy for collaboration to work on the more meaningful issues like world social, economic, racial disparities and social justice. It has been painful to watch Vietnam, but has made me aware of my responsibility to be a voice of justice in this crazy uncertain time.
Thank you for this very personal perspective of a veteran. Our nation has some serious decisions to make…