The Latin phrase that heads this column is the North Carolina state motto, adopted from the Roman philosopher and political theorist Cicero. It means “To be rather than to seem”. It is a fine motto; inspiring integrity and openness in government. In The Prince, Niccolo Machiavelli taught the reverse saying, “It is not essential, then, that a Prince should have all the good qualities which I have enumerated above, but it is most essential that he should seem to have them.” Machiavelli was coaching a prince who would soon become a ruler and he wanted his pupil to understand that it is not necessary or even advisable to always behave with integrity. All that is necessary is to SEEM trustworthy.
Proponents of North Carolina’s voter ID law understood Machiavelli’s lesson well. They would have us believe that the purpose of the law is to protect the value of every citizen’s vote by eliminating voter fraud; but they never produced evidence that fraud has affected the outcome of a North Carolina election (or that fraud exits). If they had proof, they would publish it. The leaders of the Voter ID movement only need for fraud to SEEM real so they can SEEM to be protecting the rights of voters while they selectively reduce the rights of targeted groups.
Their decisions regarding which IDs are acceptable for voting discriminate against minorities, the poor and the young. A state issued driver’s license was accepted but a state issued college ID was not. A federal military ID is ok but a Food Stamp ID is not – selectively targeting the poor and the young. The photo ID requirement, which sounds nondiscriminatory, will be discriminatory in practice. The proportion of black voters in the last election who lacked a driver’s license is more than double the proportion for white voters. Those problems demonstrate that the bill is not what it seems to be. Supporters of the new law argue that the state will provide a free ID to anyone who doesn’t have one, conveniently failing to notice that poor folks generally don’t have the certified original birth certificate, passport, or alternatives needed to get the free ID. Nor do they have time and transportation for trips to license offices to complete the application process. As Machiavelli pointed out, the sponsors don’t need to BE non-discriminatory as long as they can SEEM non-discriminatory.
During the legislative session, the Supreme Court terminated one of the protections of the 1965 voting rights act. Afterward Republicans moved quickly to supplement the Voter ID Bill with schemes that target the poor, the young, minorities, and college students. Believing that the Federal Government could no longer interfere with discriminatory laws and practices, they cut the early voting period in half, making it harder for those who depend on their churches or civic groups to provide transportation to the polls. They made it illegal for those who will soon turn 18 to pre-register as voters. They banned registering and voting on the same day, making it harder for unregistered citizens to vote. The targeted populations, of course, are ones that traditionally tend to vote for other parties.
Republican majorities on some local Boards of Election are adding their own means of disenfranchising their targets. In Elizabeth City, the Republican dominated elections board has denied students at historically black Elizabeth City State University the opportunity to run for elected office. The new Republican chairman of the Forsyth County Elections Board has proposed closing the early voting location at historically black Winston Salem State University. At Appalachian State University in Boone, not only will the on-campus polling place be eliminated, there will be over 9300 voters assigned to the new polling place which has only 35 parking spaces. There are no sidewalks between the campus and the polling place, just a dirt path along a highway.
Over recent decades, North Carolina has made huge strides in voter participation, moving from 47th in the nation in 1990 to 11th in 2012. During that period, we made it easier to vote through measures like same day registration and early voting. Now the same Republicans who cut taxes for the wealthy then failed to support public education, Medicaid expansion and unemployment benefits have implemented a voter ID law which will make it harder for those they have harmed to vote them out of office. Their new law is much more than an ID law. It will have the effect of discouraging voting, especially among minorities, the poor and the young.
On the Seal of the United States is the slogan “E Pluribus Unum” – out of many, one. It is a principle which has helped our nation become great. By disenfranchising many voters the new North Carolina law makes a mockery of both “E Pluribus Unum” and the state motto. A reversed motto, “Videri quam esse” – to SEEM rather than to BE better fits the law’s supporters but it does not fit the proud and free traditions of our state and our nation.
http://www.npr.org/2013/08/16/212664895/in-rural-n-c-new-voter-id-law-awakens-some-old-fears lack of voter fraud evidence
Bush administration 5 year study turns up no evidence of fraud: http://www.nytimes.com/2007/04/12/washington/12fraud.html?_r=2&
Annual nc voter turnout http://www.ncsbe.gov/content.aspx?ID=70
Early voting and campus voting: http://www.newsobserver.com/2013/08/19/3120626/county-elections-boards-in-nc.html
http://www.thenation.com/blog/175837/north-carolina-republicans-escalate-attack-student-voting#
http://www.journalnow.com/news/state_region/article_1bedcab6-0acc-11e3-9d20-001a4bcf6878.html